man, how boring. i wrote a big rant but i think i'll just sum it up:
-the reviewers giving it praise are mostly skeptics and fanboy-haters
-the reviewers commented on the problems you guys mentioned
-the mouse is precise, but NOT intuitive - this is both
-there will still be normal controllers, they won't force you to use this
-microsoft's campaign consists of videos of annoying teenagers, customizeable faceplates and media capabilities - buy a computer already
-sony's campaign consists of lies - hiding the same old games behind fantastic videos that are actually not real-time
do we really need another football game whose only addition for the last how many years is that you can see the angry sneer on your player's face a little clearer? if i wanted to play more war-sim shooters, i'd use my pc. if i wanted to play another ff game, i'd stab myself in the throat. at least nintendo does something new with its franchises (wind waker's cell-shading and sailing, mario sunshine's water pack, double dash's co-op system, wario ware). while everyone else just keeps shoving in beefier processors and more ram, trying to add "bling bling" to their image, nintendo is actually sitting down, thinking and taking risks. nintendo is not the senile geezer of the business, in fact they are the most profitable. i'm very disturbed at how successful raw marketing is in america. sony and microsoft are "cool", nintendo is not cool, everyone hates nintendo. noone hates apple for trying new things.
anyhoo, i will admit that you will look like an idiot swinging that thing around, but as long as you're having fun who the hell cares? i want to swing the sword instead of pushing a button, man, how fun is that?