SPLIT ATT YDS AVG LNG TD REC YDS AVG LNG TD FUM LST
2005 357 1860 5.2 95 9 54 530 9.8 48 2 1 1
(Sites don't have his official stats out yet) 370 attempts, 1880 yards, 5.2 avg, 5 fumbles, (15 receptions, 78 yards, 1 TD as of last week)
I think it's a very tough call, and that Alexander will win it out over Barber, Peyton, Palmer, Brady, or anyone else simply because of the massive TD amount.
The only argument I can think about NOT giving it to him is the talent around him, with Hasselbeck being so consistantly good this year compared the Eli being so inconsistant the past few weeks.
Edit: Another person I consider worthy is Larry Johnson, 1300+ yards, only started around 9 games, 20 TD's, I think he'd have made more noise this year had Shaun Alexander not had the huge totals